Renato's Pizza | Our Story

Our Story

Welcome to Renato's New Haven Style Pizza! We take immense pride in crafting the finest, New Haven-style pizzas that are sure to delight your taste buds. Alongside our pizzas, we offer an array of drinks and desserts. For those seeking a taste of Italy, our selection of sumptuous pastas will transport you to the heart of Mediterranean cuisine. At Renato's, we are committed to delivering an unforgettable dining experience that will leave you coming back for more.

Thin Crust, Charcoal-Fired, Twelve Years In

New Haven style means a thin, blistered crust baked in a charcoal-fired oven, and that's the only kind of pizza Carlos has made in twelve years behind the oven. Beyond the New Haven rounds there are New York Sicilian pies in both traditional and Grandma styles, and dozens of fresh and premium toppings if you'd rather build your own. The kitchen also turns out brick oven pasta, entrees, salads, burgers, and hot sandwiches.

Built Around The Char

At Renato’s, the oven is at the heart of the experience. The charcoal-fired brick oven brings intense heat, quick cooking, and that signature char that defines authentic New Haven–style pizza. With twelve years of experience dedicated to this craft, Carlos brings knowledge, precision, and passion to every crust.

28 Pies, Endless Possibilities

With 28 signature pies on the menu, there is plenty to explore. From bold combinations to rich and creative white pies, each one brings its own character to the table. Prefer to create your own? Choose from a wide selection of fresh and premium toppings and build a pie exactly the way you like it.

So Much More Than Pizza

Renato’s goes beyond the classic pizzeria experience. The full kitchen serves up comforting Italian favorites, hearty pasta dishes, appetizers, salads, burgers, and hot sandwiches alongside the signature pies. There is something for every kind of appetite, making Renato’s a place you can return to again and again.

Family Run, Neighborhood First

Renato’s is proudly run by Carlos and his family, creating the kind of welcoming atmosphere that makes a neighborhood restaurant feel like home. Friendly service, fair prices, and a genuine connection to the community are part of what makes Renato’s a favorite in the Saugatuck neighborhood.